Skip to main content
Search
Search
Quick Search anywhere
Quick Search anywhere
Quick Search anywhere
Quick Search anywhere
Quick Search anywhere
Quick Search anywhere
Advanced Search
Skip main navigation
No Access

Small shareholder control of listed companies’ administrators during annual general meetings: an experimental study

Published Online:June 18, 2012pp 46-64https://doi.org/10.1504/IJBAF.2012.047361

Abstract

In this study, we examine the perceptions of individual shareholders during Swiss annual general meetings (AGMs). Using AGMs as a corporate governance device has become ineffective; a panel of experts has called on small shareholders to increase their involvement in order to improve meeting efficacy. We designed a theatre-based experiment with 149 participants who acted as shareholders of a fictitious Swiss-listed SME. We find that active small shareholders are perceived positively by less than half the subjects. Pension fund representatives seem to instil the highest level of confidence in shareholders in their ability to maintain long-term company sustainability. Finally, we note that confidence in the board of directors fell markedly over the course of the experiment.

Keywords

theatre-based experimentation, shareholder meeting, corporate governance, risk management, manipulation, annual general meeting, AGM, corporate governance, experimental study, board of directors, shareholders, Switzerland

References

  • 1. S.E. Asch, H. Guetzkov Ed., '‘Effects of group pressure upon the modification and distortion of judgement’' Groups, Leadership and Men (1951) Google Scholar
  • 2. P. Banyard, A. Grayson, Introducing Psychological Research, Seventy Studies that Shape Psychology (2000) Google Scholar
  • 3. J-L. Beauvois, R-V. Joule, Petit traité de manipulation à l’usage des honnêtes gens (2004) Google Scholar
  • 4. J.L. Brown, J.H. Evans, D.V. Moser, '‘Agency theory and participative budgeting experiments’' Journal of Management Accounting Research (2009) Google Scholar
  • 5. A. Bryman, D. Cramer, Quantitative Data Analysis for the Social Scientist with SPSS 15 & 16 (2006) Google Scholar
  • 6. G. Charreaux, G. Charreaux Ed., '‘Vers une théorie du gouvernement des entreprises’' Le Gouvernement des Entreprises (1997) Google Scholar
  • 7. J-C. Combessie, La méthode en sociologie (1999) Google Scholar
  • 8. A. Downs, '‘An economic theory of political action in a democracy’' Journal of Political Economy (1957) Google Scholar
  • 9. H. Fenneteau, Enquête: entretien et questionnaire (2002) Google Scholar
  • 10. J.J. Foster, I. Parker, Carrying Out Investigations in Psychology (1995) Google Scholar
  • 11. M.L. Gavard-Perret, D. Gotteland, C. Haon, A. Jolibert, Méthodologie de la recherche, Réussir son mémoire ou sa thèse en sciences de gestion (2008) Google Scholar
  • 12. S.L. Gillian, L.T. Starks, '‘Corporate governance proposals and shareholder activism: the role of institutional investors’' Journal of Financial Economics (2000) Google Scholar
  • 13. É. Ginglinger, '‘L’actionnaire comme contrôleur’' Revue française de gestion (2002) Google Scholar
  • 14. C. Girard, '‘Les actionnaires minoritaires’' Revue française de gestion (2002) Google Scholar
  • 15. A. Gomes, W. Novaes, '‘Sharing of control versus monitoring as corporate governance mechanisms’' (2005) Google Scholar
  • 16. O. Isner, Manuel d’enseignement suisse des commerçants (1927) Google Scholar
  • 17. M.C. Jensen, W.H. Meckling, '‘Theory of the firm: managerial behaviour, agency costs and ownership structure’' Journal of Financial Economics (1976) Google Scholar
  • 18. S. Milgram, '‘Behavioural study of obedience’' Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology (1963) Google Scholar
  • 19. M.J. Norusis, SPSS Statistics 17.0 – Statistical Procedures Companion (2008) Google Scholar
  • 20. M. Salgado, '‘Utiliser le théâtre ‘pour’ et ‘dans’ l’entreprise’' Proceedings of the 14th International Management Association (AIMS) (2005) Google Scholar
  • 21. M. Salgado, '‘Formation au management: les vertus du théâtre en formation continue et en formation initiale’' (2008a) Google Scholar
  • 22. M. Salgado, '‘Le théâtre, un outil de formation au management’' Revue française de gestion (2008b) Google Scholar
  • 23. W. Samuelson, R. Zeckhauser, '‘Status quo bias in decision making’' Journal of Risk and Uncertainty (1988) Google Scholar
  • 24. H. Shefrin, '‘Behavioural corporate finance’' Journal of Applied Corporate Finance (2001) Google Scholar
  • 25. A. Shleifer, R.W. Vishny, '‘Large shareholders and corporate control’' Journal of Political Economy (1986) Google Scholar
  • 26. R. Sias, L. Starks, '‘Institutional investors in equity markets’' (1998) Google Scholar
  • 27. A. Smith, R.A. Campbell Ed., A.S. Skinner Ed., An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776) Google Scholar
  • 28. G. Stasser, W. Titus, '‘Pooling of unshared information in group decision making: biased information sampling during discussion’' Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (1985) Google Scholar
  • 29. J.B. Stevens, The Economics of Collective Choice (1993) Google Scholar
  • 30. G. Tüngler, '‘The Anglo-American board of directors and the German supervisory board-marionettes in a puppet theatre of corporate governance of efficient controlling devices?’' Bond Law Review (2000) Google Scholar
  • 31. A. Tversky, D. Kahneman, '‘Judgements under uncertainty: heuristics and biases’' Science (1974) Google Scholar
  • 32. M. Yoshimori, '‘La gouvernance des entreprises au Japon: les causes de son dysfonctionnement’' Finance Contrôle Stratégie (1998) Google Scholar
  • 33. () Google Scholar
  • 34. () Google Scholar
Previous article
Next article